+Hjalmar Holm Yes, at least one Silmaril has come back, while the two others remain hidden. The intended meaning of vi Gilith is 'in the sky', 'in Ilmen' ("[N] gilith = Q ilmen" Etym.s.v. WIL-).
Of course I do. It's just that I find using noun + gerund (suffix) combinations to be a bit ambiguous. Ilmen is more defined as opposed to gilith. Ilma, "starlight" and men, "way, direction, place, spot".
+Björn Fromén I am inclined to agree with +Ekin Gören. My reading of the Etymologies (Ety/GIL) is that most likely gilith = Ilma, not Ilmen, despite what it says in Ety/WIL. The likelier Noldorin cognate of Ilmen seems to be the indistinct form Gilwen (Ety/GIL), since both are derived from GIL + MEN = "star-place, shine-place".
As for gilith, I think it originated as the gerund of the verbal root GIL "shine (white)", perhaps originally having the sense "*shining", and drifted to became "starlight" by association with gil "star".
+Paul Strack Well, from 'starlight' it could as easily have developed the more specialized sense 'region of starlight'. After all the only unambiguous gloss of gilith is "= Q ilmen", with the parallel gwilith (*'flying' >) "'air' as a region = Q vilwa".
Björn Fromén Jun 24, 2015 (23:47)
Hjalmar Holm Jun 25, 2015 (10:51)
Björn Fromén Jun 25, 2015 (23:08)
The intended meaning of vi Gilith is 'in the sky', 'in Ilmen' ("[N] gilith = Q ilmen" Etym.s.v. WIL-).
Ekin Gören Jun 27, 2015 (02:01)
http://eldamo.sourceforge.net/content/words/word-2541963429.html
Ilmen however is indeed given as "Place of Starlight". I'm not sure what gilith should mean but I'd opt for menel to say "sky".
Björn Fromén Jun 28, 2015 (17:59)
Ekin Gören Jun 28, 2015 (22:28)
Paul Strack Jun 29, 2015 (05:04)
As for gilith, I think it originated as the gerund of the verbal root GIL "shine (white)", perhaps originally having the sense "*shining", and drifted to became "starlight" by association with gil "star".
Björn Fromén Jun 29, 2015 (14:47)