In the Etymologies, the answer is trivially bad- from BAT, but since then, no derivatives of the root do appear in texts marked 'Sindarin'. (There is, of course, batân in Adûnaic, but it also precedes PE17 and other relevant sources). In PE17, Tolkien toys with an idea of proposing some ba(n)
Hjalmar Holm Apr 17, 2015 (22:19)
Paul Strack Apr 18, 2015 (17:12)
I agree that the whole thing becomes easier to explain if we assume the root is BAT.
The only thing I can add to your analysis is that GL has a verb G. bad- "travel" (GL:21), so the verb bad- had a long history in Tolkien linguistic conceptions.
Александр Запрягаев Apr 18, 2015 (18:36)
menasbothS. and Q. root for movement. But his reluctance to replacegovannen(*govenwould be such a nice cognate to Q. omen(ta)-, and I don't believe Mae govennen is somehow worse sounding!) in this case [might have been just his feeling that any printed text is fixed] indicates to me the only possible solution: BAT should be restored. He spends too much time discusslng BAN 'beauty, lack of blemish' for that; also, S. baw 'don't' is not really consistent with any movement ideas.Personally, I'd untangle the web somehow like that: in Q., MEN is movement to a particular destination and (E)DEL(E) is journeying; in S., when DEL gets junked except in Edhil, LEN is extrapolated instead; and for MEN, which disappears except i•ven 'way' and gets restored in verbs only to 3rd Age under heavy Quenya influence, moving with a destination in mind is originally bad- or gwa-, which is, indeed, derived from 'depart' > 'go away' > just 'go (esp. to another place, away from speaker or current position)'. Hence, trevad-, govad- and etc. are relevant.
Paul Strack Apr 18, 2015 (19:05)
I don't think the case for rejection of BAN is quite that clear. Tolkien also "definitely" rejected AL|LA = "not" on the same page, only to restore it again later and then reject it again (VT42:33, VT44:4).
I am quibbling, though. I agree with you that the restoration of BAT is the simplest explanation of govannen. Given that BAT is glossed "tread" in the Etymologies, I think it is likelier that bad- means "walk" or perhaps "travel", as for its Quenya cognate vanta- "walk". I think "depart" would be gwae- from the distinct root WĀ/AWA (PE17:148), cognate of Q auta-.
Александр Запрягаев Apr 22, 2015 (15:56)